| 1627 | William Moore, Captain |
| William Cowle, Ballacowle, Warden of the Day Watch | |
| David Christian, Warden of the Night Watch | |
| 1644 | David Christian, Cranstal |
| 1662 | William Christian, Ballayonaighue |
| 1681 | Ewan Christian, Cranstal |
| Between the late 17th century and 1838, six generations of Ballayonaighue, all named William Christian, were in office | |
| 1838 | Frederick John Dominique LaMothe, Ramsey, MHK before 1864 |
| 1864 | William Callister, Thornhill, Lezayre, JP, MHK 1847-72 |
| 1873 | John Corlett LaMothe, Ramsey, son of F J D LaMothe, MHK 1867-79, Secretary of Keys 1884-98 |
| 1880 | Arthur Cowle Kayll, Ramsey, MHK 1877-82 |
| 1891 | John Burnyeat, Grenaby, MHK 1887-91 |
| 1897 | Charles Banks Nelson, Ramsey |
| 1900 | Daniel Teare, Ballaskilley, MHK 1887-91 |
| 1907 | Rovert Edward Garrett, Ballaghennie |
| 1922 | Daniel Joughin Teare, St Bridget’s and Ballaskilley, MHK 1919-42, MLC 1942-43, son of D Teare |
| 1943 | John Joseph Teare, Ballaskilley, his brother |
| 1957 | Ewan Bridson Curphey Farrant, Ramsey, MBE, JP, MHK 1934-46 & 1950-54, MLC 1954-64 |
| 1964 | Alfred Cecil Teare, Ramsey and Ballaghennie, MHK 1953-61 |
| 1971 | William Daniel Christian, Ballakeigh |
| 1981 | William Daniel Christian, Ballakeigh, his son |
